Markus Babbel Criticises A-League Referees – Right or Wrong?

Sacked Western Sydney Wanderers coach Markus Babbel had seemingly left the game in Australia on good terms.

The below tweet is a five minute message from the German as he thanks everyone who helped him during his time at the club.

He was universally praised for his class at a time when many would understandably be frustrated and angered at losing their job.

However, in the immediate aftermath of his departure, he has taken aim at the A-League and described it as a ‘slow’ and ‘weak’.

The spotlight was well and truly on the officials in his interview with German newspaper Bild.

“I was stolen eight points this season, it is incredible how bad the referees are doing”, he said.

“If you know our referees and see what’s going on here, that’s blatant. My mistake was that I publicly denounced it early on and then became the focus.

“But honestly, I did not understand until the end what they are whistling.”

It is safe to say that the A-League is a far cry from the likes of the European leagues; competitions Babbel once competed in as a player for German powerhouses Bayern Munich and English giants Liverpool.

Having never represented a professional side outside of his home continent, perhaps Babbel’s opinion could be seen as a fresh take on a league that needs serious adjusting.

Or, it’s a naïve and misguided take from someone who doesn’t properly comprehend the current state of the game in Australia.

Let’s take a more in-depth look at Babbel’s time at the Wanderers.

The Wanderers had been only two points off the finals in the season before Babbel joined, managing two draws against runners up Newcastle and a win over semi finalist Melbourne City during the regular season.

33 points from 27 games is hardly a success, but it was anything but a disastrous season.

After being named head coach in May of 2018, Babbel struggled to deliver consistent results.

The Wanderers only managed 24 points from the 27 regular season fixtures, conceding the third most amount of goals and falling 16 points short of a finals berth.

After the previous season gave many fans hope of a potential return to finals, Babbel and the Wanderers fell further down the pecking order.

In a 2-0 loss to fierce rivals Sydney FC, Babbel was sent off after an outburst following a disallowed goal from Roly Bonevacia.

Sydney FC defender Michael Zullo was deemed to have been impeded by Jaushua Sotirio in the lead up to the goal. There was a distinct lack of protest from Sydney players and coaches, with many conceding that they had, well, conceded.

Referee Chris Beath disallowed the goal after a VAR check, sent off Babbel after he let his frustrations be known and the German’s first impression of A-League refereeing was hardly a good one.

Many sympathised with Babbel, claiming it was an error from the officials.

Babbel also expressed frustrations at the referees following a 4-3 loss to Perth Glory.

Babbel isn’t afraid of letting his feeling be known and many warmed to him during his tenure at the Wanderers, mainly for how upfront and honest he was.

However, his targeted attacks at referees can be seen as either one of two things.

On one side of the coin, they were excuses for when his team lost or didn’t perform to the level that he desired.

On the flip side, he was saying it how it was and calling out the referees for the poor calls they made.

One would not envy the job of a referee during a professional game. They have one of the toughest jobs in sports.

They know their decisions will never go down as universally praised and the split-second decisions they do make can sometimes be criticised to the nth degree.

There will never be a game that is ‘perfectly officiated’, but at the same time, we’d be fools to ever believe something like that could eventuate.

Perhaps refereeing does need a touch-up in this country. Maybe more training is needed for some of the most commonly criticised members of the Australian soccer community.

But maybe, just maybe, Babbel failed to understand that the Australian game is significantly different to that of the European leagues, where he had spent his entire life.

It’s a fascinating issue and we’d love to hear your thoughts and opinions on Twitter @Soccersceneau

Previous ArticleNext Article

Mapping the Future: GIS Innovation Takes Off in Australia

Global Institute of Sport (GIS) is expanding its influence in the Asia-Pacific, in particular, Australia where they have already made significant progress and will be opening a brand new campus.

GIS is a leader in sports education, offering innovative online and in-person courses at campuses and iconic sports venues around the world, including the likes of Wembley Stadium in London, Chase Stadium in Miami, and Melbourne’s MCG.

But it’s Australia where GIS is now focusing its attention and they’ve already made some big strides.

In episode four of Soccerscene’s Off the Pitch podcast, Asia-Pacific Regional Director Ray Boggiano spoke about the progress GIS has made in Australia so far.

“We’ve had the MCG partnership since 2019, so we’ve been doing our first summit, so study tour was in January 2020, we had a couple of virtual ones in between and then we brought our students back for the last couple of years as well,” he said in the podcast.

“From last year we started doing these residentials, so we have various sites, the MCG, Darebin, our partner clubs like Preston, they’re signed off as sites that we can deliver for face-to-face teaching for our British programs.”

Additionally, Boggiano spoke about the new GIS campus opening in Australia next year.

“Our vision and something that’s very soon to be realised is to have a sports campus in Australia,” he said.

“We will be opening the doors to our Sydney campus next year so our first intake will be in January 2026.

“The partnership is with the University of Newcastle, but it’s with their Sydney CBD campus, and also in partnership with Venus NSW, so very pleased to be able to use the Allianz Stadium and the SCG as well, so we’ve got access to two incredible stadiums.”

Boggiano also added that the new campus will be taking applications as soon as this month and highlighted the importance of Australia to GIS.

“We will be starting to take applications likely from April this year and the first intake will be January 2026, so this is a major milestone for us,” he said.

“We have always had Australia central to our strategy, it is really a vibrate sports economy, sports market, and sports industry.

“Over the next ten years that’s only going in one direction with obviously the build-up Brisbane games in 2032.”

The new campus will offer a wide range of degrees and industry-focused programs designed to give students the skills they need to succeed in the global sports industry.

To hear and learn more about GIS, you can listen to the full interview with Ray Boggiano on episode four of Soccerscene’s Off the Pitch Podcast, available on all major podcasting apps and here.

Football Queensland Forms Regional Partnership with McDonald’s

Football Queensland (FQ) is excited to announce McDonald’s as the Official Quick Service Restaurant Partner for the Far North & Gulf region.

Under the two-year regional collaboration, McDonald’s will take on naming rights to the home of football in Cairns, with Endeavour Park now officially named Macca’s Park.

The partnership also includes support for grassroots football, with McDonald’s backing local clubs and celebrating junior players across the Far North and Gulf through the weekly MiniRoos Player of the Week voucher initiative.

FQ General Manager – Northern Conference, Craig Ramage, said the partnership was a major win for the region, highlighting FQ’s continued focus on growing the game in regional Queensland.

“This is an exciting opportunity to partner with an iconic brand in McDonald’s, whose long-standing support of community football aligns strongly with our vision for the game across the state,” he said via press release.

“We’re proud to extend this relationship into the Far North & Gulf, with the support from McDonald’s set to deliver direct benefits to grassroots programs, local clubs and junior players right across the region.

“The renaming of Endeavour Park to Macca’s Park is a powerful symbol of this partnership and our shared commitment to creating vibrant and welcoming regional football hubs that inspire the next generation of participants and bring communities together.”

McDonalds Far North Queensland Marketing Manager Jill Lennox, expressed that the partnership reflects the company’s ongoing commitment to supporting active lifestyles and local communities through sport.

“Active lives are happier and healthier lives. McDonald’s wants to deliver valuable benefits to the wider community. With the goal of helping people live a more balanced, active and enriched lifestyle, McDonald’s is passionate about its sports and community sponsorships program,” she said via press release.

“McDonald’s is very proud to be the naming rights sponsor to the home of football in Cairns now known as Macca’s Park. This partnership is our way of giving back to the community which supports us and to assist in the development of important life skills such as commitment, hard work, and friendship.

“On behalf of McDonald’s, we would like to thank all competitors, parents, organisers, volunteers and other sponsors for their incredible support of Football Far North and Gulf region and we look forward to seeing you at Macca’s Park soon.”

This alliance marks an exciting chapter for football in the Far North & Gulf, as Football Queensland and McDonald’s work together to support the growth of the game across the region.

Most Popular Topics

Editor Picks

Send this to a friend