Shay Boyle: Developmental issues send more and more young domestic players abroad

The tyranny of distance remains a challenge for many young Australian footballers looking for opportunities abroad, yet domestic developmental issues for talented teenagers like Shay Boyle also play a role.

Australian parents spend tens of thousands of dollars on academy and registration fees from a very young age; often over-estimating the talent their son or daughter possesses. They are tempted by fame and fortune and lured into the trappings of football professionalism, potentially unaware of just how difficult the road can be.

With obvious failings in Australia when it comes to development, it is highly likely that a significant percentage of our best young players are not fulfilling their enormous potential by remaining on local shores. That fact is causing more and more players to look and head abroad in search of the skills and knowledge required to be a top class professional.

There is a vast chasm between the talented Aussie youngster, seemingly with magic at their feet and the polished and experienced professionals in the lower leagues of European football. No doubt, our best young players can succeed if given the opportunity abroad, however, knowing the recruitment and scouting game is paramount. Parents with experience in it could potentially have much to share with those less versed in the idiosyncrasies of the system.

One man with plenty of experience and nous when it comes to such matters is James Boyle. A Scotsman, he immigrated to Australia in 2010 and in 2018 launched the Football Business Network; an organisation designed to forge connections between the football and corporate worlds, providing mutual benefit.

An astute coach, Boyle has experience at numerous Sydney based NPL clubs and will be working under Rydalmere FC head coach Gavin Rae in season 2020.  He also has a talented young footballer for a son.

The eldest of his twins, Shay, has recently taken a leap of faith and ventured abroad; granted a spot at the Fleetwood Town FC International Football Academy. The club competes in England’s third tier, League One and stands a chance at promotion after some excellent recent form.

The academy aims to locate and enlist international talent oft dismissed in its domestic setting, something Shay has lived his entire footballing life thanks to his diminutive frame.

The young Boyle has found his football pot of gold with Fleetwood Town. After years of toil, disappointment and some success, a trial with Getafe FC’s youth academy and some interest from Scottish giants Celtic, led to a scout making contact with the Boyle’s in the land down under.

Fleetwood Town were interested and after viewing a professional and extensive YouTube clip that featured edited highlights from hours and hours of his play, Shay was offered a six month placement and flew to the northern hemisphere just before Christmas.

The senior Boyle to me expressed his undeniable belief in the importance of such a professional digital package being presented to prospective clubs. Mounting a compelling case for an international academy to take a punt on a young man from the other side of the world is a challenge, yet Shay’s presentation convinced Fleetwood Town that there was indeed something worth pursuing. The teenager’s professional journey has begun, albeit far from home.

Not a tall boy, Shay has battled against perceptions of physical weakness throughout his career. Year after year, the now 16-year-old was told that his skills were more than adequate, yet that the modern game accommodated few players of his stature. Footballers continue to improve as athletes and the thinking appears to be that potential at a young age is measured by frame size and not always the skills possessed by the athlete.

Boyle has been dogged by such opinions in the Australian domestic scene. Frustrated, his view is that his son may never have received such recognition in his adopted home, thanks to a valuing of size above skill.

It is undoubtedly true that more and more imposing men are taking up the game around the globe and the next generation will once again prove to be bigger and more powerful than the next. Yet for every menacing centre-back, there is a dexterous genius capable of embarrassing the taller and more cumbersome man.

Shay Boyle has always been that player. After watching the scouting clip, it is clear he is undoubtedly skilled and blessed with a football mind and spatial vision. James constantly used former Italian International Andrea Pirlo’s words, “Football is played with the mind and the feet are the tools” as he worked with Shay as a junior footballer.

That sentiment has been the cornerstone of his development as a player.

Socceroos and Olyroos coach Graham Arnold recently called for further investment in the national youth teams, also stating that he sees little being done to develop domestic talent. Whilst Boyle is now receiving the tuition and competition he requires to test himself, Australian football has lost another promising player and depth.

Boyle senior has set up a Facebook page to assist parents of Australian players and arm them with the knowledge required when it comes to pathways towards international academies and opportunities abroad.

Visit YSA – Youth Soccer Australia – Information and Agency on Facebook.com, follow the page and use the collective wisdom of coaches, administrators and parents to inform your knowledge of the sometimes confusing structures in professional football.

Previous ArticleNext Article

The Footballing Figures Recognised in January 26 Honours List

In an announcement made on Monday, four individuals were celebrated in the January 26 Honours List for their respective services to the football industry in Australia. 

The cohort included Football Tasmania CEO, Tony Pignata, PFA Founder and former CEO, Brendan Schwab, former Football Australia CEO, Ian Holmes and former player and Matildas’ manager, Alen Stajcic. 

 

Leaders of Australia’s football landscape

Tony Pignata

Recipient of the Medal of the Order of Australia (OAM) is Football Tasmania CEO, Tony Pignata. 

From beginnings as a player for Box Hill Inter, to several leadership roles with clubs like Wellington Phoenix, Sydney FC and Perth Glory, Pignata has dedicated his life to the game. Since 2023, he has led Football Tasmania and helped to develop high-performance pathways and expand participation to ensure football has a long-term future in the region. 

Brendan Schwab

PFA Founder and former CEO, Brendan Schwab, was recognised with the Member of the Order of Australia (AM). 

Schwab’s contributions to football are undeniable, not only as a key figure in the creation of the PFA in 1993 and the A-League, but as an accomplished lawyer who advocated for Australian footballers on the global stage. As a Football Australia Hall of Fame Inductee and PFA Champion, Schwab has undoubtedly woven his name into the fabric of Australia’s football industry. 

Ian Holmes

Former Football Australia CEO, Ian Holmes, was another recipient of the Medal of the Order of Australia (OAM). 

With contributions to football in Australia spanning five decades, Holmes stands as an essential figure in the industry. His work has covered various levels of the game, including as President of New South Wales Amateur Soccer Federation, Football Australia CEO, and Director of Football New South Wales. His leadership and commitment has been pivotal to the growth of football at state and national levels. 

Alen Stajcic

Former player and football manager, Alen Stajcic, was awarded the Medal of the Order of Australia (OAM) for his services as a coach. 

In both the men’s and women’s game, Stajcic has forged a successful record on the international stage for the Matildas and the Philippine Women’s National team, as well as at club level for Sydney FC, Central Coast Mariners, Perth Glory and Western Sydney Wanderers. As Head Coach from 2014-2019, Stajcic helped the Matildas reach new heights on the pitch and thus pave the way for the development of the women’s game across the nation. 

 

Acknowledging dedication and commitment 

Whether in Australia or beyond, the football industry can be an unforgiving and ruthless sphere in which to work. This is why recognising the people who have made valuable contributions to the nation’s footballing landscape is so important. Through consistent hard work and commitment, they collectively helped to bring the football industry in Australia to where it is today. 

While development is constant and improvements can always be made, it is reassuring to know that the foundations were built with the help of four dedicated individuals deservedly recognised in this year’s January 26 Honours List.

 

See the full 26 January Honours List here.

Coach Education Exchange unites Football NSW and Japan FA

The education program was a roaring success for the 14 coaches who made the trip, demonstrating Japan’s high-quality infrastructure and development systems from which football bodies across Australia can take inspiration. 

 

A valuable partner

The 2026 FNSW Japan Coach Education Exchange comes as the latest display of the strong connection between footballing worlds in Australia and Japan. 

14 Football NSW coaches travelled to Japan for unique insights into what makes the J-League and WE League tick. With both of these leagues being renowned for their distinct footballing identities, elite development pathways, and technical excellence, the program serves as a valuable opportunity for Football NSW to gain new ideas and know-how moving forward. 

During the visit to Japan, the coaching cohort visited several different clubs, including: 

  • Cerezo Osaka
  • Tokyo Verdy
  • JEF United Chiba
  • Urawa Red Diamonds
  • Gamba Osaka

Learning from international expertise

The trip was not, however, merely about uncovering the secrets to club or commercial success. 

Visits to the JFA Academy Sakai emphasised Japan’s commitment to creating elite pathways for talented young players across the country. They believe in nurturing players not only to be talented footballers, but to be confident leaders through their education and lodging system. 

“He or she being gifted does not always have his or her talent blossom. By providing those who have a talent with a good environment and encouraging them to make efforts, we nurture players who can shine in the world,” they explain via the JFA official website

Further meetings with Director of Coach Education at the JFA, Kimura Yasuhiko, as well as Head Coach of Japan’s Men’s National Team, Hajime Moriyasu, highlighted the wealth of knowledge which Australia can access during collaborations with the JFA. 

“The opportunity to meet and hear from a national team head coach operating at the highest level of international football proved both humbling and motivating, underscoring the value of global connection and shared learning in coach development,” Football NSW said via press release. 

Following the success of the 2026 FNSW Japan Coach Education Exchange, the objective should now be to transform insights into action. For Football NSW, or any other football association in Australia seeking to develop the game for current and future generations in the region, the lessons learned from international partners must be applied with real conviction and commitment.

 

Most Popular Topics

Editor Picks

Send this to a friend