Shay Boyle: Developmental issues send more and more young domestic players abroad

The tyranny of distance remains a challenge for many young Australian footballers looking for opportunities abroad, yet domestic developmental issues for talented teenagers like Shay Boyle also play a role.

Australian parents spend tens of thousands of dollars on academy and registration fees from a very young age; often over-estimating the talent their son or daughter possesses. They are tempted by fame and fortune and lured into the trappings of football professionalism, potentially unaware of just how difficult the road can be.

With obvious failings in Australia when it comes to development, it is highly likely that a significant percentage of our best young players are not fulfilling their enormous potential by remaining on local shores. That fact is causing more and more players to look and head abroad in search of the skills and knowledge required to be a top class professional.

There is a vast chasm between the talented Aussie youngster, seemingly with magic at their feet and the polished and experienced professionals in the lower leagues of European football. No doubt, our best young players can succeed if given the opportunity abroad, however, knowing the recruitment and scouting game is paramount. Parents with experience in it could potentially have much to share with those less versed in the idiosyncrasies of the system.

One man with plenty of experience and nous when it comes to such matters is James Boyle. A Scotsman, he immigrated to Australia in 2010 and in 2018 launched the Football Business Network; an organisation designed to forge connections between the football and corporate worlds, providing mutual benefit.

An astute coach, Boyle has experience at numerous Sydney based NPL clubs and will be working under Rydalmere FC head coach Gavin Rae in season 2020.  He also has a talented young footballer for a son.

The eldest of his twins, Shay, has recently taken a leap of faith and ventured abroad; granted a spot at the Fleetwood Town FC International Football Academy. The club competes in England’s third tier, League One and stands a chance at promotion after some excellent recent form.

The academy aims to locate and enlist international talent oft dismissed in its domestic setting, something Shay has lived his entire footballing life thanks to his diminutive frame.

The young Boyle has found his football pot of gold with Fleetwood Town. After years of toil, disappointment and some success, a trial with Getafe FC’s youth academy and some interest from Scottish giants Celtic, led to a scout making contact with the Boyle’s in the land down under.

Fleetwood Town were interested and after viewing a professional and extensive YouTube clip that featured edited highlights from hours and hours of his play, Shay was offered a six month placement and flew to the northern hemisphere just before Christmas.

The senior Boyle to me expressed his undeniable belief in the importance of such a professional digital package being presented to prospective clubs. Mounting a compelling case for an international academy to take a punt on a young man from the other side of the world is a challenge, yet Shay’s presentation convinced Fleetwood Town that there was indeed something worth pursuing. The teenager’s professional journey has begun, albeit far from home.

Not a tall boy, Shay has battled against perceptions of physical weakness throughout his career. Year after year, the now 16-year-old was told that his skills were more than adequate, yet that the modern game accommodated few players of his stature. Footballers continue to improve as athletes and the thinking appears to be that potential at a young age is measured by frame size and not always the skills possessed by the athlete.

Boyle has been dogged by such opinions in the Australian domestic scene. Frustrated, his view is that his son may never have received such recognition in his adopted home, thanks to a valuing of size above skill.

It is undoubtedly true that more and more imposing men are taking up the game around the globe and the next generation will once again prove to be bigger and more powerful than the next. Yet for every menacing centre-back, there is a dexterous genius capable of embarrassing the taller and more cumbersome man.

Shay Boyle has always been that player. After watching the scouting clip, it is clear he is undoubtedly skilled and blessed with a football mind and spatial vision. James constantly used former Italian International Andrea Pirlo’s words, “Football is played with the mind and the feet are the tools” as he worked with Shay as a junior footballer.

That sentiment has been the cornerstone of his development as a player.

Socceroos and Olyroos coach Graham Arnold recently called for further investment in the national youth teams, also stating that he sees little being done to develop domestic talent. Whilst Boyle is now receiving the tuition and competition he requires to test himself, Australian football has lost another promising player and depth.

Boyle senior has set up a Facebook page to assist parents of Australian players and arm them with the knowledge required when it comes to pathways towards international academies and opportunities abroad.

Visit YSA – Youth Soccer Australia – Information and Agency on Facebook.com, follow the page and use the collective wisdom of coaches, administrators and parents to inform your knowledge of the sometimes confusing structures in professional football.

Previous ArticleNext Article

Victorian Football’s Revival: How Disruption Is Reawakening the Game’s Heart

A surge of ambition is reshaping Victorian football. From packed grandstands to club reinvention, the game is thriving again — and policymakers must keep up.
Heidelberg United players celebrating after a goal during their Australia Cup run, showcasing Victorian football disruption

Victorian football disruption is changing the landscape of the game. Crowds are growing, clubs are modernising, and communities are reconnecting with football like never before. What we are seeing is more than competition on the pitch. It is a reawakening of local football’s heart and identity.

When the right policies and investments are in place, clubs thrive, communities benefit, and the football economy grows. This moment shows exactly why disruption can be the best thing to happen to Victorian football in years.

A New Standard: Preston Lions Leading the Disruption

Few clubs capture the spirit of Victorian football disruption better than Preston Lions. Back in NPL Victoria, Preston is averaging around 5,000 fans per match, a figure that reflects a strong community connection and a modern professional approach. Their marketing, digital presence, and engagement strategies are setting new standards for Australian football.

Preston’s success is forcing other clubs to raise their game. It shows what happens when a club combines authenticity, ambition, and professionalism.

Grand Final Passion and Heidelberg’s Cup Inspiration

The NPL Victoria Grand Final captured the essence of Victorian football disruption. Over 9,000 fans packed Lakeside Stadium to watch Heidelberg United and Dandenong City put on a show that proved how strong the local game has become.

Dandenong City’s passionate fans and Heidelberg’s tradition created one of the best football atmospheres in recent memory. Heidelberg’s fairy-tale run in the Australia Cup, defeating three A-League clubs to reach the final, proved that Victorian clubs can compete with anyone in the country.

Tradition Meets Change Across the League

The disruption runs deep. South Melbourne, despite fighting off relegation, claimed the Dockerty Cup. Melbourne Knights, a club that has produced legends like Mark Viduka, were relegated. It is a reminder that history alone is no longer enough.

Victorian football disruption has made it clear that adaptability, community focus, and modern operations define success today.

Infrastructure and Experience: Oakleigh Cannons Set the Standard

Off the field, Oakleigh Cannons are about to unveil their $15 million grandstand, a major step for Victorian football. The new facilities include improved spectator viewing, indoor training areas, and corporate entertainment spaces that elevate the entire match day experience.

When Oakleigh hosted Preston earlier this year, the atmosphere was incredible. The sound, the energy, and the passion from both sets of supporters showed how infrastructure can bring football to life.

These kinds of investments are not just about comfort or prestige. They draw people in, create jobs, and inject confidence and capital back into the game.

Unlocking Football’s True Potential

Removing the barriers holding football back showcases the very best of Australian sport. Victorian football disruption is driving new investment, stronger participation, and greater confidence in the game. We are only custodians of football, and how we manage this moment will shape its future for generations.

As we move into the Australian Championship, clubs and fans are demanding more from policymakers, including investment, infrastructure, and a clear pathway that rewards ambition.

Promotion and relegation should be part of that journey. International markets show how powerful that model can be in fueling growth, competition, and opportunity.

A Game Reborn Through Disruption

Victorian football disruption is not just about change. It is about renewal. The crowds are returning, clubs are evolving, and the culture feels alive again. The combination of passion, professionalism, and community spirit is rewriting the story of local football.

This is only the beginning. Victorian football has always had the heart. Now it has the belief to match.

From Rejection to the World Cup: How Craig Goodwin Defied Every Setback to Live His Football Dream

Craig Goodwin playing for the Socceroos

When current Adelaide United captain and Socceroo, Craig Goodwin, was asked in his formative years what occupation he wanted to pursue, his definitive answer was,

“I want to play professional football”.

However, in his endeavour to realise this dream, Goodwin encountered many obstacles.

Notably ,  he understood the competition to reach the top wasn’t always going to be easy but was determined nothing would stand in his way .

Accordingly, he was totally dedicated to the cause of furthering his career beyond all boundaries.

Influenced and coached by his father Tony, a Crystal Palace supporter who brought the family to Australia in 1967, from the age of five, Goodwin was never without the ball.
“From the age of eight, Craig really started to show his commitment and capability,” says Tony Goodwin.

Craig always revealed natural ability but wasn’t a standout even at the age of twelve”, he added.

He was selected for the S.A. State  u/13’s but was rejected for u/14 selection because of his lack of stature.

“Craig was very disappointed with his non selection but this inspired him to work harder”,says Tony Goodwin.

On a family trip back to England, Goodwin trialled with the Crystal Palace u/15’s and really excelled. Unfortunately, he  failed to gain an apprenticeship because he fell into the age group of u’16’s.

However, he was asked to come back to trial for the u/18’s  two years later and despite impressing, they didn’t require a flanker, only a central striker.

Argentina's Lionel Messi, left, is greeted by Australia's Craig Goodwin at the end of the World Cup round of 16 soccer match between Argentina and Australia at the Ahmad Bin Ali Stadium in Doha, Qatar,
Argentina’s Lionel Messi, left, is greeted by Australia’s Craig Goodwin at the end of the World Cup round of 16 soccer match between Argentina and Australia at the Ahmad Bin Ali Stadium in Doha, Qatar.

After this, he went to Scotland and trialled for Inverness where he was offered an apprenticeship to start the following June.

However, the night before he was bound for Scotland, the impossible happened when he was advised the Inverness Academy had been culled because the senior team was relegated.

Despite the devastating news and disappointment, Goodwin just declared” he would get on with it”.

This involved spending countless hours on core body work and running up hills with his father to increase his strength.

Despite this application, he was cut from the Adelaide United youth squad trials for the second time.

Fortunately, while still at the Adelaide Raiders, Goodwin received a call from Oakleigh Cannons coach, Arthur Pappas, who had been tipped off about the youngster’s ability by an Adelaide contact.

“I was naturally disappointed in being knocked back a second time for the Adelaide United youth team so I saw a move to Melbourne with Oakleigh as a step forward”, says Goodwin.

While he was playing for Oakleigh in the winter, Goodwin caught the eye of Melbourne Heart coach, John Aloisi,and in the summer of 2011, he made his debut in the National Youth League.

Subsequently, he received the call up from John van’t Schipp to play in the senior Heart team as a wing back against Melbourne Victory.

Goodwin made a huge impact in the match, nutmegging Harry Kewell and leading Marco Rojas and Ivan Franjic such a merry chase , he received the man of the match.

It was none other than former Socceroo great Ray Baartz who witnessed the talents of Goodwin in this match.

“I advised the Newcastle Jets, General Manager, Robbie Middleby, to get that kid up to Newcastle as soon as possible”.

“You could see the boy had a special talent running at defenders with a deadly left foot shot to boot”, added Baartz.

Middleby responded quickly and Goodwin accepted the offer to sign with the Jets which would guarantee him first team football for the 2012-13 A-League season.

“In the second match of the season , we played away at the Sydney Football Stadium against Sydney FC  who paraded the talents of Del Piero and I scored for the Jets and won man of the match”, says Goodwin.

Goodwin’s exploits were heeded by Socceroo coach, Holger Osieck, and he received a call up for the national team in a match against Japan and also appeared in the East Asia Cup against China.

“It was a daunting experience to be selected for the Socceroos in my first season at the Jets  but an amazing feeling sharing the limelight with Golden Generation players like Lucas Neil”.

“Ironically, I didn’t play for the Socceroos again until the 2016 match against England at the Stadium of Light”.

Adelaide beckoned Goodwin after two seasons at the Jets and the club agreed to the move reluctantly.

Goodwin spent two seasons back home before his agent arranged a move to Eridivisie outfit, Sparta Rotterdam.

“ It was a good move for me because Rotterdam is a football mad town”, says Goodwin.

“In the first season I was a regular starter and was awarded man of the match in the home game against Feyenoord”.

“Significantly, the last match of the season against Go Ahead Eagles  was a must win for the club to survive relegation”.

“Playing off the bench I scored a goal and provided two assists which was hopefully a good omen for the following season”.

In that following season ,Goodwin did score a few goals but after a 7-0 loss to Feyenoord, the coach was sacked and replaced by Dick Advocaat who signed thirteen new players.

Unfortunately, Goodwin wasn’t in Advocaat’s plans but no club was prepared to pay Sparta a loan fee for his services.

“This affected my selection chances for the 2018 World Cup Finals , although I’d been in the squad for the qualifiers”.

After this unsavoury experience, Goodwin was happy to return to Adelaide for the 2018-2019 season and made a big contribution, scoring 10 goals in 29 matches.

News travels fast in the football world and before he knew it ,Goodwin’s agent arranged a lucrative move for the Socceroo to play in the Saudi League for Al- Wedha on loan where he played from 2020- 2022 before returning to Adelaide for the 2022-23 A-League season.

After winning the Johnny Warren Medal in the A-League for the 2022/23 season, Goodwin’s services were sought by his former Saudi Club, Al-Wedah.

It was a lucrative offer which Goodwin couldn’t refuse and despite some injury problems, he still scored 12 goals from 46 appearances.

“The Saudi League is really on the improve and when I rubbed shoulders  with the likes of Cristiano Ronaldo, Steven Gerrard, Karim Benzema,  and Jordan Henderson amongst others, I knew my time had arrived”.

“I was even able to swap shirts with Benzema and Henderson”.

Now he is back in Adelaide on a three year contract for probably his last club , Goodwin looks back with great pride in his achievements, despite so many roadblocks in his career.

“ I always believed you had to learn from setbacks because they would provide the inspiration to reach the next stage in the game”, says Goodwin.

“I look back with extreme pride, especially with my thirty appearances for the Socceroos”.

“It was touch and go whether I would ever play in the 2022 finals in Qatar as I didn’t touch a ball in preseason due to injury”.

“However, lots of painkillers for training and matches worked for me and the great relationship I had with Graham Arnold and the playing group were big factors in my revival”

“It was a memorable moment when I scored the opening goal in the first match against France, despite the 4-1 defeat”.

“In the second match against Tunisia, we knew we could win the battle and no inch was given to them”.

“In the final group match against Denmark I played in the first half, and from the bench in the second half, I’d never been so nervous until Matthew Leckie scored that magnificent winning breakaway goal”.

In the second round match against Argentina, it was stunning the way the Socceroos played to restrict Argentina to a 2-1 scoreline and many observers stated it was one of the greatest performances by a Socceroo team.

“The fact I came on as a second half substitute in the 58th minute was something I will cherish forever ,playing on the same pitch as Lionel Messi and Co.”

Craig Goodwin’s latest challenge is back in Adelaide where he prepares for the A-League season.

His loyalty in returning to Adelaide United has been beyond reproach over the years.

Significantly, Goodwin has received a number of lucrative offers, preferring to give his blood, sweat and tears for his home town and the fans who worship their star player.

“The three year contract  will enable me to make a  full contribution to the team”.

“There are several fresh faces who will strengthen the depth of the squad and I’m confident in our prospects”.

“Yet we’re not getting ahead of ourselves”.

“We need to be difficult to break down defensively while improving our counter press to put our opponents under considerable pressure”.

Also, if any of Adelaide United’s opponent this season underestimate the power and accuracy of Goodwin’s shooting boots, they do so at their own peril

More importantly , this season is critical for Craig Goodwin as he  wants to lead the Adelaide squad to a high position in the A-League.

Foremost in his mind is the World Cup in North America next June and July.

Nothing in this world would give Goodwin any greater pleasure than Tony Popovic selecting him in his final squad for the Greatest Show on Earth.

“It would be a fitting finale to my international career and extreme justification for all the challenges I’ve experienced along the way”.

Proudly Sponsored by: PCFS Logistics – Click here to find out more

Most Popular Topics

Editor Picks

Send this to a friend