Why the barriers for female coaches must be eliminated

Heather Garriock Canberra

Last Monday night (May 24) saw Football Coaches Australia (FCA), in tandem with representatives from all across the Australian football family, invest their time into a FCA Women’s Football Webinar discussion around the immense challenges facing Australia’s female football coaches in the pursuit of their careers.

The panel discussion, hosted by Aish Ravi, who is currently undertaking a Doctor of Philosophy with a focus on women’s coaching education in football, FCA CEO Glenn Warry and Matildas legend Heather Garriock (FCA Vice-President, Football Australia ‘Starting XI’ representative and current CEO of Australian Taekwondo), aimed to provide insight into the barriers for female coaches in Australian football, and by extension, wider society.Garriock Profile Photo

Notably, Heather Garriock’s role as CEO at Australian Taekwondo reflected not just the difficulties in finding roles as a female footballer or coach after one finishes their playing career, but the loss of talented and passionate individuals to roles away from football.

“If we don’t start investing in our females within our game, we are going to start losing them. And as we can see with Heather, we’ve lost someone who’s played over 100 games for Australia and has been a pioneer in the women’s game. For me, that is really sad to see,” remarked Western Sydney Wanderers legend Catherine Cannuli.

Cannuli, who balances her time between her seasonal duties as assistant coach at Western Sydney Wanderers and as the Women’s Technical Director at the Southern Districts Soccer Football Association, admitted to facing a dilemma in how to progress her career to where she wants it to be because of a lack of stability in women’s coaching roles that are typically part-time.

Cannuli Coaching“For me now, I’m in a very hard place. Being a new mother, having to worry about my son now and wanting to have that stability, if I want to progress my career and make the step towards becoming a full-time head coach in a professional environment,” she said.

“For me, I’m in a very stable situation with my association, but is it where I want to be? If I want to progress as a head coach and get into that professional side, do I take stability in my full-time role or do I take the risk in becoming a head coach in a part-time role?”

Perth Glory legend and manager of Bristol City through three Women’s Super League (WSL) seasons since 2018, Tanya Oxtoby, acknowledged that despite the fact that the WSL is a full-time setup there are some critically similar challenges facing both the W-League and WSL.

“It’s a full-time role. All the players are full-time, all the stability that Catherine was talking about, we have that. But there are still similar barriers in having to fight for those rights every single day. And that’s a shame that in 2021 we are still having to push the boundaries and ask for what is fair. It doesn’t come voluntarily and that’s a shame unfortunately,” she said. Tanya Oxtoby Photo

And in response to Garriock pondering what is fair, Oxtoby conveyed: “For me, I’ve just had a little boy and changing attitudes towards coaches, whether you’re a female coach coaching men’s football or women’s football, has to change. That for me is what’s fair; seeing people through equal eyes and that does not always happen. Trying to educate people on what’s appropriate and what’s not, it’s difficult, and you’ve got to be a strong character to go through that.

Aish Ravi, in her studies on the experiences of female coaches in Australia, has worked to understand the strategies that can be formulated to overcome these challenges.

“From what I understand, the literature tells us that women are underrepresented in coaching football and there are very few women in some of these positions from coaching all the way through to analyst positions and to Technical Director positions,” she said.Aish Ravi Photo

“In terms of lived experience, from what I understand and what the literature says, women do feel highly scrutinised in some of these positions and there is a pressure to overperform and gain credibility. And sometimes that can be afforded to others as opposed to some women. So, we do need to find out what these strategies are in the context of the unique Australian footballing landscape, as they can then be provided to inform these organisations on how to improve the space for women coaches.”

What proved to be particularly pertinent was the lived experience of an attendee in the webinar.

As a female coach making the transition between working in a major city’s footballing environment to the setup in a smaller rural town, the attendee remarked how astronomically challenging it is to grow the women’s game because of a lack of initiative on the part of the outfit who runs football there. And critically, the opposition to change stems from a board that is bereft of female representation.

Ros Moriarty, Chair at the Football Australia Women’s Council and Managing Director and Co-founder of John Moriarty Football, spoke on the inequality in workplace culture in Australian football.Ros Moriarty Photo

“A workplace is a workplace, and football is a workplace. If a coach is being paid for her work, then she can expect that a workplace will have the basic tenants that we all hope and wish for, and fight for; that you don’t have to ask for things that are simply part of you doing your job,” she said.

“Culture is about attitude and it’s about respect, but I think culture also plays into structure. We have a problem in Australia because we don’t have a full home and away season for the W-League, so coaching in the W-League isn’t full-time. So, the Women’s Council have been pressing for a really long time about making sure under the new arrangements with the clubs that full home and away eventuates.”

With a Women’s World Cup to be co-hosted by Australia and New Zealand in 2023, the time to start delivering on the passion for the women’s game is now, not in two years when it is beneficial to a select few in the short term. There is impetus, as there always has been, for all stakeholders to help lead change in the women’s football space.

And despite the fact that the resilience of Australia’s female footballing contingent has been perpetually undervalued all throughout its history, there remains a constant drive and determination to instigate change in Australia football for players and coaches. Discussions, like the one that took place on Monday, mirror this sentiment. Moreover, it is essential for Australian football’s variety of stakeholders to take in and to learn from the discussion that was had in order to aid in the fight for equality in Australian football.

Football Coaches Australia presents ‘The Football Coaching Life Podcast’ S3 Ep 2 with Gary Cole interviewing Steve Corica

Corica FCA

Steve Corica is Head Coach of A-League Men at Sydney FC, where he narrowly missed out on three A-League Championships in a row, losing to Melbourne City in the Grand Final last season. What a remarkable start to his first senior head coaching role!

He played his junior football in Innisfail in North Queensland, before heading to the Australian Institute of Sport and playing just under 500 professional games in Australia, England and Japan.

Steve’s preparation for coaching began while he was playing, and he started to gain his coaching licences before taking on an assistant role with the Sydney FC Youth Team.

He served a seven-year apprenticeship at Sydney with the Youth Team and then as an assistant to Vitezslav Lavicka, Frank Farina and Graham Arnold before taking on the Head Coach role in 2018. He learned from each of these coaches and also learned, like most ‘he didn’t know, what he didn’t know’ when taking on the Head Coaching Role.

Steve believes that team and club culture are key to success. He understands that while he is the driver of the culture, that buy-in from all of the players is integral to behaviours being demanded from the playing group of one another.

Steve’s ‘one piece of wisdom’ was ‘to be yourself’. Know how you want to play, the style of football you want to play. Be strong when you do get setbacks, but believe in what you’re doing, stay strong and keep believing in the style of football you want to play.

Please join me in sharing Steve Corica’s Football Coaching Life.

Zena Sport: Helping female goalkeepers stay protected

Donna Johnson started Zena Sport with the aim of protecting women athletes in high-impact sports. With the help of her husband, former AFL footballer and Western Bulldogs captain Brad Johnson, Zena Sport is changing the way female athletes look at injury prevention.

Their Female Impact protection garment, known as the Zena Z1 performance vest, offers support and impact protection, while also giving compression for enhanced post-game recovery.

The impact vest isn’t visible under a jersey or shirt while being lightweight and breathable without restricting a player’s movement, weighing only 160 grams.

Donna came up with the idea after after she watched a local women’s AFL game, with plans to continue expanding the product line after their initial success.

“My wife Donna was at a local game with her best friend who had a couple of daughters playing, and one of them came off that game with a big knock to the breast,” Brad said.

“We thought is there anything to help these girls during that development phase of life? That’s how the conversation started with us, and we continued to explore it.”

After discovering there wasn’t a large body of research in the area of injuries specific to women’s athletes, Zena Sport conducted their own.

“We worked with Deakin University in that process, and there were a lot of things to tick off,” Brad Johnson said.

“We went through their Centre of Sports Research, and the vest has been validated to show it absorbs a high level of contact.”

The AFLW embraced the impact vests, and now Zena Sport is expanding into other sports.

“The last 18 months we’ve been going flat out, AFLW was our first port of call but Melissa Barbieri jumped onboard quickly and she loves wearing it in goal,” Donna said.

“Soccer is one sport that the vest has been well received, and the feedback has been great so we want to push it even further and harder through the soccer world.”

Melissa Barbieri, a former Matilda’s goalkeeper, had an early opportunity to test the vest out before launch.

“Once I tried it I felt that little more protected in collisions, and as a goalkeeper hitting the ground and the ball hitting your chest,” Barbieri said.

“I have some breast cancer in the family, so I wanted to protect myself as much as possible, so it was a welcome revelation.”

Barbieri, who played 86 times for Australia, values the product as perfect for women goalkeepers who need extra safety during games.

“First and foremost I feel it gives you compression, which is always good for recovery, but it also gives you an extra layer of protection from any hits you might have via the ground, opposition coming in or friendly fire,” she said.

“Certainly when you are in a one-on-one predicament in a game, coming out and spreading yourself with as much width as possible and not protecting yourself in the chest area, it’s perfect for feeling that little bit of extra protection.”

Brad Johnson is the Western Bulldogs’ all-time appearance holder in the AFL, and his own experiences in professional sports influenced the design of the vest.

“It was always wait until you are injured, and then protect it to return to play. In that regard, I wore a rib-guard in the final few years of playing, under my jumper without anyone knowing, and away I went,” he said.

“So from that I was keen to add that element to it which has become a really popular part of the vest.”

For Barbieri, the impact vest not only offers her safety and confidence on the field, but she also believes in the company behind the product.

“Supporting someone who is so passionate about female athletes is really great to see, and it’s a homegrown family company, so I want to get behind them as much as much as possible,” she said.

Zena Sport is providing women and girls the opportunity to play contact sport to their full potential while raising awareness about the need to protect themselves from injury.

You can visit the Zena Sport website for more information, or view the ZENA Z1 Impact Protection Vest.

© 2021 Soccerscene Industry News. All Rights reserved. Reproduction is prohibited.

Most Popular Topics

Editor Picks