Manchester City must pay the ultimate price for financial cheating

Manchester City’s financial scandal has reached boiling point. On the 29th of September, an independent commission found City guilty of all charges relating to serious breaches of the league’s financial rules across nine seasons, from 2009/10 to 2017/18. The commission also upheld three of four charges concerning the club’s failure to cooperate with the Premier League investigation.

The Premier League says City used sham commercial arrangements and disguised owner funding to inflate revenue and reduce costs by more than $1.7 billion (£900 million). Abu Dhabi United Group funded $1.58 billion (£830.69 million) that appeared in City’s accounts as sponsorship money from Abu Dhabi companies. The commission concluded that City’s accounts concealed the true financial position from auditors and regulators.

The 115 charges cover inaccurate financial information, player and manager payments, financial rules and the investigation itself. City has lodged its appeal against the guilty verdict, but for such a serious sporting scandal, attention has already turned to the potential punishments. In a Premier League era where foreign investment is king and revenues have skyrocketed, we should be asking questions. How did Manchester City get away with this for so long, and how can the punishment act as a deterrent to keep the reputation of football’s biggest league intact?

The hack that exposed the story

The most uncomfortable part of this saga is how the authorities discovered it and how most likely City never would have been exposed. In 2018, German publication Der Spiegel published leaked internal City emails and documents obtained through Football Leaks. Rui Pinto, the Portuguese hacker behind Football Leaks, supplied material that alleged City had disguised owner investment as sponsorship revenue and manipulated arrangements to satisfy financial regulations.

The Premier League investigation began in December 2018. City were formally charged in February 2023, after a four-year investigation, and the hearing finally began in September 2024. That timeline is nothing short of extraordinary; eight years between the leaks being exposed and charges being brought to Manchester City does significant sporting damage.

Man City won eight major titles during the alleged period, including three Premier League titles. Recalling titles in any sport leaves a sour taste in any sports fan’s mouth. The fans of opposing sides given titles feel robbed of the special moment, and Manchester City fans could feel rightfully deceived. But it goes beyond even this as we look at who Manchester City signed during those seasons. Players such as Ilkay Gundogan and Kevin De Bruyne played vital roles in City’s later titles beyond the 2017/2018 season. Would they have joined if this had been uncovered earlier? It’s impossible to say, but it shows how City’s early investment from 2009/10 still contributed to their titles in the 2020’s.

The Premier League’s credibility

That delay is not just embarrassing for City; it damages the Premier League. The league is the most competitive and commercially powerful domestic competition in football. Its rules are supposed to create a framework in which clubs compete on sporting merit while remaining financially sustainable. If a club can allegedly distort its accounts by hundreds of millions of dollars and the process takes years to reach a verdict, despite City’s potential obstruction, every other club has a reason to question whether the system works.

The irony is obvious: if Football Leaks hadn’t shared what they found on Manchester City through its hack, the scheme never would have been uncovered. If financial rules were designed to stop clubs gaining an unfair competitive advantage, then the Premier League may need to change how it investigates how its clubs’ finances are being managed. If anything should be gained from this, it may be that financial regulation needs to be improved as the Premier League and its clubs spend billions.

As for Manchester City, punishment cannot simply be a fine that becomes another operating cost.

Relegation is the only serious answer

If the verdict survives the appeal, Manchester City should be removed from the Premier League and those three aforementioned league titles removed. A fine would be inadequate and, depending on what points deduction City got, would punish the club in one season while leaving the historical record largely intact. Nottingham Forest received a four point deduction for a charge of Profitability and Sustainability rules in 2023-2024. City’s 114 charges will see much greater punishment then that.

Even if City are relegated they would almost be guranteed to be promoted the next season so even that feels like a slap on the wrist. Despite their investment during the nine seasons being questioned their five titles subsequent to that period will be expected to remain in their hands. My solution is to relegate City to the Championship without the potential of promotion for three seasons, one for each title won during that time.

City fans will call that harsh but their is strong reason to come down hard and that’s because this is bigger than Manchester City. Foreign ownership has brought huge investment into English football, but investment cannot mean exemption from the rules. Owners, executives and clubs must know that the Premier League’s financial regulations carry consequences that cannot be negotiated away.

The league has a choice. It can impose a manageable punishment and move on, or it can demonstrate that competitive integrity matters more than the commercial power of its biggest clubs. If City’s appeal fails, the answer should be clear: relegation, a reckoning over the titles and a message to every owner that the Premier League’s rules are not optional.

Previous ArticleNext Article

Further fragmentation for Aussie football fans as DAZN & Disney split UEFA competition rights

British over-the-top streaming platform DAZN are set to win the Australian UEFA Champions League rights for the next four seasons from 2027/28, while Disney will acquire the rights for the Europa League and Conference League competitions.

According to SportBusiness, Disney will hold exclusive rights for all three tiers of UEFA club competition in New Zealand.

The Champions League has been broadcast on Nine’s Stan Sport platform since 2021, while DAZN has held the rights in New Zealand.

It marks the second time in four seasons the rights for the competition have changed hands in Australia, indicating that top level European football is indeed a desirable asset for broadcast companies.

Paramount+ had been favoured to win the Champions League rights to supplement their football offering, having acquired the rights from next season in the USA, Canada, the UK & Germany among other markets, but opted against placing a bid in Australia.

The news is yet another blow to the consumer; the splitting of UEFA competitions means yet more fragmentation for Australian football fans. Seperate subscriptions are already required to watch the English Premier League (Nine), the domestic A-Leagues and national teams products (Network 10/Paramount+), while the Championship has a free-to-air home on SBS.

The news comes just months after Nine paid AUD 800 million to extend it’s deal to show the Premier League; they will be banking on the majority of its audience to favour the top English domestic league as opposed to watching Europe’s finest clubs in Real Madrid, Barcelona et al.

Data from the Australian Government 2023 Census Survey on Online Copyright Infringement showed that 39% (four-in-ten) of Aussies said they illegally streamed live sports on the internet.

With rising costs to streaming football imminent, there is a good chance these numbers rise again.

Thornaby FC’s community commitment leads the way, but football fans continue to suffer

The cost of living crisis has impacted people and businesses worldwide and football is no different.

Football fans globally – and especially top flight British supporters – are being priced out of the game they created, and by the teams they have supported their whole lives.

In the 2024/25 season, 19 of 20 Premier League clubs raised their ticket prices. The highest single jump was a 28% increase, and additionally an 11% hike on tickets for children. Between 1990-2025, football fans in the UK have seen their ticket prices increase by an immense 800%. 

The fan reaction has been continually damning. Via the UK-based Football Supporters’ Association, over one hundred supporter groups campaigned for Premier League clubs to freeze ticket prices at home games for two seasons, as part of the Stop Exploiting Loyalty Campaign.

An FSA statement reads: ‘Football is for everyone. Rising prices are making it harder for regular fans, especially younger generations and working-class communities to attend matches.’ 

With fans of clubs from right across the country united on the matter, their position was clear: stop taking football from the people.

One club that did heed the message were North Yorkshire non-league side, Thornaby FC. This season, they are offering free season tickets to local residents for both men’s and women’s games.

Over 20,000 people are eligible thanks to the partnership between the club and the local council. With the club awarded AUD 12,000 (GBP 6,500), the initiative aims to bring the community together and drive locals to games.

This is not seen as a final solution, but certainly a major step in gaining support and interest for the team; in turn it will hopefully drive local investment, revenue and growth via the community that supports it, as opposed to investment groups that potentially hold less interest in the health of the club and its community. 

The Stop Exploiting Loyalty Campaign has also gained the support of MPs in Parliament. In March, they recognised the problem and as part of an Early Day Motion stated: ‘working-class and young supporters are being priced out; squeezing out local and dedicated fans poses an existential threat to the culture and community of football.’

While those words may be encouraging, what they can change in their current systematic position feels minimal.


The World Cup is another example of football fans suffering greatly at the hands of commercial interests.

On the grandest stage, where fans from around the world gather en masse to support their nations and the spirit of the game should in theory be at its most authentic, fans are deliberately exploited by FIFA.

According to Forbes Middle East, the 2026 edition in the USA, Canada and Mexico saw a rise in ticket prices for 90 of the 104 matches compared to the previous edition in Qatar.

Football is being held up by investors and governing bodies like a puppet on strings. They deem growth to be the only measure of success.

Growth is of course a key requirement of success, but what good is that when it sees the interests of local communities, including loyal football fans, pushed to the side? When it comes to modern day football, good deeds – such as those committed by Thornaby FC – are rarely seen as time well spent.

The pursuit for growth is also not just financial. Human attention is a newly monetised market; from streaming views to social-media engagement to email sign-ups. As football continues its global push into lounge rooms and onto smartphones, it is at major risk of overlooking those who commit their time and resources to stand in the terraces or sit in the stands.

Most Popular Topics

Editor Picks

Send this to a friend