The Caceres Clause controversy: History repeats in Auckland

The ‘Caceres Clause’ has come into question from teams and fans across the A-League about how newly formed Auckland FC were able to make a move for Alex Paulsen on a loan move from sister club AFC Bournemouth.

The rule was originally introduced in 2016 to prevent transfers and loans between related clubs after Manchester City was able to sign Anthony Caceres from the Central Coast Mariners and was immediately loaned out to Melbourne City.

However, the Australian Professional Leagues (APL) has released a statement on the A-Leagues website saying the rule will be reviewed before the upcoming season:

“The APL was approached by numerous clubs in May about the possibility of reviewing the ‘Caceres Clause’ due to the increased transfer market opportunity for clubs as well as changes in the broader club ownership structures in place since the inception of the player contract rule in 2016,” the statement read.

A review process was implemented to get feedback from all clubs about the rule change considering:

  • If any guardrails would be required
  • The league and club’s emphasis on youth development
  • Improving overseas talent pathways
  • Increasing opportunities for international player transfer and loan fees

From this, a player contracting rule change was supported by all clubs, with the premise that the APL reviews and maintains certain guardrails that balance the development of the league while ensuring competition integrity.

The update the APL provided also said:

  • At the end of every season, the APL reviews the Player Contract Regulations and Competition Policies and Regulations in line with feedback from key stakeholders.
  • Any rule change is subject to approval by Football Australia as part of the Player Contract Regulations and Competition Policies and Regulations with the APL that occurs ahead of each season.

General Manager of Wellington Phoenix, David Dome, replied to the news with a statement seeking further information about the rule change and Paulsen’s loan deal to Auckland FC.

“While the club in principle supports adapting the ‘Caceres Clause’ to allow Paulsen to return to the Isuzu UTE A-League for the 2024-25 season, it has a number of questions that have yet to be answered,” he said via a media release.

“Most importantly we don’t know what “player registration and salary cap treatment guardrails” will be in place that the APL say will “balance development of the A-League while ensuring competition integrity.

“We also note all player contract regulations and competition policies have yet to be approved by Football Australia.”

Paulsen’s pending move back home to Auckland raises many questions about not only the rule itself but also the landscape of how transfer and loan deals are done moving forward in the A-League.

Besides Auckland FC – Melbourne City, Melbourne Victory and Perth Glory are all part of multi-club partnerships and if this move is approved, we may see these clubs make similar moves to gain a competitive advantage.

Football Australia has not announced if the rule has been officially changed at the time of writing which means Paulsen is still unable to be registered as an official Auckland FC player, despite the announcement.

It’s a matter of time until we see the final verdict on this saga, but it will be intriguing to see if the deal falls through because of the ‘Caceres Clause.’

Previous ArticleNext Article

Thornaby FC’s community commitment leads the way, but football fans continue to suffer

The cost of living crisis has impacted people and businesses worldwide and football is no different.

Football fans globally – and especially top flight British supporters – are being priced out of the game they created, and by the teams they have supported their whole lives.

In the 2024/25 season, 19 of 20 Premier League clubs raised their ticket prices. The highest single jump was a 28% increase, and additionally an 11% hike on tickets for children. Between 1990-2025, football fans in the UK have seen their ticket prices increase by an immense 800%. 

The fan reaction has been continually damning. Via the UK-based Football Supporters’ Association, over one hundred supporter groups campaigned for Premier League clubs to freeze ticket prices at home games for two seasons, as part of the Stop Exploiting Loyalty Campaign.

An FSA statement reads: ‘Football is for everyone. Rising prices are making it harder for regular fans, especially younger generations and working-class communities to attend matches.’ 

With fans of clubs from right across the country united on the matter, their position was clear: stop taking football from the people.

One club that did heed the message were North Yorkshire non-league side, Thornaby FC. This season, they are offering free season tickets to local residents for both men’s and women’s games.

Over 20,000 people are eligible thanks to the partnership between the club and the local council. With the club awarded AUD 12,000 (GBP 6,500), the initiative aims to bring the community together and drive locals to games.

This is not seen as a final solution, but certainly a major step in gaining support and interest for the team; in turn it will hopefully drive local investment, revenue and growth via the community that supports it, as opposed to investment groups that potentially hold less interest in the health of the club and its community. 

The Stop Exploiting Loyalty Campaign has also gained the support of MPs in Parliament. In March, they recognised the problem and as part of an Early Day Motion stated: ‘working-class and young supporters are being priced out; squeezing out local and dedicated fans poses an existential threat to the culture and community of football.’

While those words may be encouraging, what they can change in their current systematic position feels minimal.


The World Cup is another example of football fans suffering greatly at the hands of commercial interests.

On the grandest stage, where fans from around the world gather en masse to support their nations and the spirit of the game should in theory be at its most authentic, fans are deliberately exploited by FIFA.

According to Forbes Middle East, the 2026 edition in the USA, Canada and Mexico saw a rise in ticket prices for 90 of the 104 matches compared to the previous edition in Qatar.

Football is being held up by investors and governing bodies like a puppet on strings. They deem growth to be the only measure of success.

Growth is of course a key requirement of success, but what good is that when it sees the interests of local communities, including loyal football fans, pushed to the side? When it comes to modern day football, good deeds – such as those committed by Thornaby FC – are rarely seen as time well spent.

The pursuit for growth is also not just financial. Human attention is a newly monetised market; from streaming views to social-media engagement to email sign-ups. As football continues its global push into lounge rooms and onto smartphones, it is at major risk of overlooking those who commit their time and resources to stand in the terraces or sit in the stands.

FIFA lose court ruling to UEFA over scuppered FFE plan

Last Thursday (Nov 12), a New York City judge denied requests made by FIFA subsidiaries to block a move by UEFA, who filed court documents in August pursuing information relating to FIFA President Gianni Infantino’s failed World Cup private investor plan.

Nine days after the 2026 World Cup, FIFA and Infantino officially put forward the FIFA Forward Enterprise proposal (FFE) which shook the football world to its core.

The plan was to sell a minority stake (roughly 20%) in the governing body’s competitions to private investors, but was cancelled in the following days due to intense backlash and boycott threats from UEFA and CONCACAF, and varying levels of distaste from other confederations.

Lawyers representing UEFA are seeking evidence from Joshua Kushner’s New York investment firm Thrive and FIFA advisors JP Morgan surrounding the FIFA backed investment plan.

In an eight-page document written by the judge, they said the attempted block by two FIFA subsidiaries failed because they “do not have a direct, substantial and legal protectable interest” in the proceedings. 

‘Nothing in this record indicates that the U.S. FIFA parties, or even FIFA itself, will be parties in the contemplated criminal proceedings,’ the ruling stated.

After the immense fallout between FIFA and UEFA, Infantino said the project had ‘created divisions’ and become ‘no longer in the interest’ of its original objective.

The FIFA President had offered its 211 member associations $40 million USD ($59 million AUD) if they supported the proposal which would see all FIFA competitions privately invested in, including the men’s and women’s World Cups.

The investment would have seen the younger brother of U.S. President Donald Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, be the financial anchor of the venture. 

The fallout of FFE was undeniably the biggest crisis Infantino has faced during his near-eleven-year stint as FIFA president, although he remains the favourite to win reelection for another term in March.

Most Popular Topics

Editor Picks

Send this to a friend