Growing younger: PFA report challenges A-League Men critics

Professional Footballers Australia released their annual A-League Men’s report last week, which indicates the wheel has turned against two persistent criticisms of the league: a lack of opportunities for young players, and the recycling of similar faces between clubs commonly described as ‘player churn.’

The report highlights that the competition led all leagues within the Asian Football Confederation last season in providing opportunities for players aged under 21, with steady growth across the past three seasons decreasing the average age of the league from 27 years to 25.

The signing of a five-year collective bargaining agreement ahead of the 2020/21 campaign between the PFA and its players also provided clubs and players a degree of stability not previously afforded. This has seen contract lengths increase across the board, allowing clubs to move away from the need to sign players at short-notice, and therefore reliance on ‘known quantities.’


TALENT FACTORY

A key point to emerge from the report is that perceptions that the league leans heavily on the tried and true, and is reluctant to roll the dice on young talent, is no longer accurate. Within the AFC, the league topped all for the percentage of match minutes played by those under 21, at 11.1% of minutes across its 257 matches.

This places it comfortably ahead of its nearest competitors in Asia: the Arabian Gulf League – sitting second with 9.3% of minutes allocated to players in the bracket. The J2 League (Japan’s second division) was third with 5.5%. Japan’s J1 League, widely considered Asia’s strongest league, sat fifth with 5.4%.

Globally, Australia’s figure placed it eighth on a list of 60 comparable leagues, considerably behind the world leading Danish Superliga and Venezuela’s Primera Division, tied on 16.5%. Notably, A-League Men’s sits above the Dutch Eredivisie (10.9%), commonly considered one of world football’s strongest development leagues. However, it should also be considered that the figure is drawn from 306 matches, as opposed to Australia’s 257.


France’s Ligue 1 leads all comers across Europe’s ‘Big Five’ on 9.1%, ahead of the German Bundesliga (7.1%) and England’s Premier League (4.4%).

Brisbane Roar’s Kai Trewin (2,416 minutes) and Central Coast Mariners’ Jacob Farrell (2,338) topped A-League Men minutes for players in the age bracket in 2021/22; Farrell and Sydney FC’s Patrick Yazbek were both within the world’s Top 100 players to play the most senior football in the first half of 2022, from the under 20 bracket (CIES Football Observatory).

How has this happened? The reduction of the A-League’s salary cap from $3.2million to $2.1million during the nadir of Covid-19 in October 2020 played a significant role. Paired with global travel restrictions, inhibiting foreign recruitment during the period, clubs were forced to look inwards and become resourceful, rather than spending bloated figures on overseas recruits.

The updated CBA brokered by the PFA in September 2021 will see the cap gradually rise back to $2.6million by 2024 and features greater flexibility for clubs to spend outside of it. But some clubs, having been forced to live lean during crisis time, are in no hurry to return to their old ways.

The Central Coast Mariners developed a well-earned reputation for the promotion of their own in the club’s formative years, largely through financial necessity. Mile Jedinak, Trent Sainsbury and Mat Ryan all made their professional debuts in Gosford, and would each go on to captain the Socceroos. 

Post-Covid, the Mariners are back at it under Nick Montgomery. In 2022 they ranked 17th among 40 leagues globally for percentage of minutes played by academy players: 47.1% of all minutes of 22 matches, , shared among eleven homegrown products (CIES Football Observatory).

For context, the famed Ajax academy provided 39.7% of their senior sides’ total minutes from 12 players across 29 matches (ranked 34th). The global leader was Slovakia’s MSK Zilina, sharing 85.5% of minutes across 23 academy players (28 matches).

THE NEXT STEP

The report also proves that clubs and players have used these heightened match minutes for youngsters productively, with players developing onto the next stage of their careers at an increasing rate.

A-League Men clubs have stitched themselves back into the global player market this year, taking a combined $3.4million in international transfer receipts across the January & May-September transfer window. Socceroos Connor Metcalfe, Kye Rowles and Nathaniel Atkinson headline the list of those to move abroad.

This figure demonstrates a bounce back from the seven-year low of 2021, when clubs pocketed a collective $1.6million. 2022 is still someway off the league’s highpoint of $5.4million (2018), which included moves for Daniel Arzani to Manchester City and Andrew Nabbout to Urawa Reds.

CHURN OUT

The report also shows steps have been taken towards the reduction of ‘player churn’, whereby a small, familiar pool of players are recycled amongst clubs, leaving fans bemoaning unimaginative recruiting and being unable to form a loyal connection with those on the pitch.

The percentage of players coming off contract at the start of 2021/22 was the lowest it had been in the eight years of recorded PFA contract data, at 48%. The previous low was 52% in 2015/16, while at its highest the figure blew out to 68% at the start of 2020/21, which came in accordance with the league’s Covid-inflicted salary cap reduction.

PFA research conducted in partnership with Twenty First Group also reveals the A-League Men’s leads all Asian leagues for contract length; at 1.51 years on average, longer than local competitors in the J1 League (1.01 years) and South Korea’s K League 1 (0.86).

Club’s attitudes towards long-term contracts have shifted markedly under the five-year CBA. The number of players on one-year deals has been reduced from 51% in the pre-pandemic season of 2019/20, to 39% last season. Conversely the percentage of players offered the stability of a two-year deal grew from 38% to 48%.

“The objective of agreeing to a five-year CBA was to provide both a genuine partnership between the players and the clubs and crucially to provide the professional game with a stable platform to rebuild the industry,” PFA co-chief executive Beau Busch said as part of their report.

“Encouragingly, we continue to see a range of positive trends in relation to increased investment in players, the emergence of a host of talented players and improved contractual stability.”

Previous ArticleNext Article

Ernie Merrick: ‘There are many clubs that would be fantastic additions to the A-League’

Ernie Merrick will be forever recognised as a key figure through the A-League’s golden early years. Appointed Melbourne Victory’s foundation manager in 2004 he led the club to not just silverware, but legitimacy and respect in a serious sport city.

A Scottish migrant and PE teacher by trade, Merrick was the youngest of the NSL’s managerial crop when he started with Preston in 1987 in the era of Thomson, Arok & Matic; when he finished with Newcastle in 2020 he was the elder statesman in the A-League age of Postecoglou, Popovic and Arnold.

For the places the game took him and all he achieved – including time as national team manager of Hong Kong – Victory supporters can comfort themselves in the fact that for whatever they feel towards Merrick and his iconic group of players, that feeling is mutual.

‘Yes, definitely,’ Merrick told Soccerscene Unfiltered when asked if managing Victory was the highlight of his career.

‘I think success is [fans] having identification with players, especially. We had Victorian boys playing for Victory.

‘That second year I was determined to have a complete pre-season. Archie Thompson bought me a birthday cake with 200 candles and said “Ernie, we’ve had 200 training sessions. We should celebrate this” – so he was looking forward to a big year, and we won the Grand Final 6-0.’

Nearing 20 years on, Victory and the A-League in general haven’t managed to drive forward as would have been hoped. Unsurprisingly that comes as painful to Merrick, as does the change in landscape regarding his other great passion and contribution in player development. 

‘I’m disappointed, as would most people be, that it’s struggled so badly. To me, there’s something missing,’ said Merrick of the current state of the A-League.

‘Those players we produced at the AIS and VIS went on to be the golden generation. Unless the league is fixed, there’s going to be ongoing problems with the financial status of things.

‘You just cannot earn enough money from selling a youngster, who you might get a million for, who then becomes worth several million in a few years if he does well. Maybe there’s a bit too much of selling players early.’

As someone who gave enduring service across Australia’s two domestic leagues, his voice holds weight in the consideration as to whether it’s time to now blend the, in today’s hyper-corporate landscape.

‘South Melbourne and Preston are two clubs that are perfect for the A-League, I think, down the track. They’ve set up, they’ve endured, they’ve been resilient, they’re playing good football and they’ve got a home base with a home crowd, which is far better than starting a club up from scratch.

‘All those players coming through those squads and the number of supporters they’ve got would be a huge addition. In Sydney too, there’s Marconi – there are so many good clubs around that I think would make a great addition to the A-League.’ 

Merrick also spent thirteen years as head coach at the Victorian Institute of Sport. He feels modern player development is an equation we still haven’t got right, post the closure of the AIS’ football program in 2017.

While many argue the move to club-based academy structures has seen Australia fall more in line with global practice while still producing players of quality, Merrick still feels there is merit in a national high performance program, in addition to club academies.

He was in the process of setting up state academies through the Member Federations during his time as Football Australia’s chief football officer from 2022-25. While the Victoria project was short-lived, academies in Tasmania, Western Australia and South Australia continue to run, but it appears the broader expansion of the concept has been abandoned.

‘I think both systems should work [together] equally well. When I started with the FA program clubs thought they would lose players to us, but I didn’t take any of their players. We offered the opportunity of a high-performance program to other youngsters.

‘We could develop players completely; we weren’t restricted to playing 4-3-3 to combine with the way the first team were playing. We provided more of a rounded education, and good players can play in any system.

‘We managed to affect the coaches involved so they were up to date with the latest information on methods of coaching, etc.’

Catch the full chat with Ernie Merrick on Soccerscene Unfiltered: from being two-footed by a 15-year old Kevin Muscat to his enthusiasm for the future of the Socceroos, his memories of Wellington and Newcastle, and plenty more…

Grassroots Investment is key to ensuring passion for Australian football remains – and grows

Australian football is continuing to grow, with record attendances and TV viewership up year-on-year due to the increasing value and demand of games across the country.

What started as a small ember stoked by a cultural heritage brought from Europe, has borne a league invested in by foreign states and major global equity firms, and a country that consistently supports its national teams at major tournaments globally; the fire is truly alive. But, can it be sustained and given even more life?

Ann-Marie Balliana, secretary of Illawarra club Fairy Meadow United, spoke with Soccerscene.

‘The biggest challenge for football in this country is how to take advantage of huge grassroots numbers and translate this into support for other levels of the game,’ said Balliana, formerly a long-term CEO of Football South Coast.

‘Instead of capitalising on this huge asset of participation numbers, it appears football is unfortunately bound by limited investment and various layers of internal boundaries.

‘There are lots of opportunities for football to rise to the next level, and significant work required to get there.’

The World Cup proves football belongs in Australia:

The success of the Socceroos in reaching the last six consecutive men’s World Cups has greatly boosted the domestic interest in football, with the 2026 World Cup highlighting how far the team has come, and how many people are behind them to succeed.

The SBS and SBS On Demand coverage of the tournament reached over 18 million Australians (64% of the population) and over 209 million hours were consumed via these sites.

Meanwhile, over 10,000 dedicated fans paid up to AUD $25,000 to watch their country participate live in North America. 

I took in the tournament from Melbourne, and the energy among the city was undeniable. Bubbling with excitement were people conversing who usually wouldn’t, and there lay an air of calm between the 90 minutes of euphoric nation-wide highs. 

Federation Square was at full capacity (7,500) for many of the group games and the knockout match against Egypt- despite the 4.00am kick-off time.

Alongside that, AAMI Park held 6,000 more spectators in the early hours of the day for the knockout game. Despite the time zone killing any convenience, the fans diligently showed up.

The post-World Cup glow also took effect: Queensland selling out both recent friendlies against Brazil.

World Cup 2026 TV ratings

Match Overall reach Average audience viewership Key detail
Final: Spain vs France 5.26m (peak) 2.69m Most watched World Cup match in SBS history
Australia vs Paraguay 4.84m 3.09m Highest viewed fixture for Socceroos
Australia vs Turkey 4.78m 3.04m Top performing early fixture

The rise of the domestic game persists:

Domestically too, figures show Australian football is continuing to grow.

October’s 2026 Australia Cup final between South Melbourne and Melbourne Victory was not only a match that will be remembered by fans for its entertainment and underdog storyline, but for investors and governing bodies that can clearly see the growing market for football in this country.

AAMI Park had its record attendance broken as 29,911 spectators packed in to watch the game. Furthermore, the TV viewership of the Cup final had a 56% increase from the previous year. The demand for football is growing significantly.

A-League Stats and Records 2025/26 season:

  • 3 sold out finals games- 22% increase on attendance last season.
  • 27% increase in digital viewership on Paramount+ and 17% on 10 Streaming.
  • For the last four seasons, over 1.3 million fans have  attended games throughout the campaign
  • TV viewership exceeded 11 million views.
  • Social media reached over 7 million people (10% increase).
  • Newcastle Jets, Adelaide United and Perth Glory all broke their previous attendance records.

The Cup final saw a non A-League club win the trophy for the first time in competition history.

South Melbourne fans. Credit SMFC

‘It also showed that NPL clubs such as South Melbourne have a fantastic support base, and this shows the potential of football to really capitalise on the community support that does exist for clubs,’ said Balliana.

‘The costs of running an A-League club are clearly the biggest issue in growing our national competition, and without significant investment through broadcast, government and other revenue streams, there are limited opportunities to take advantage of huge grassroots numbers.’ 

England is widely regarded as having the best domestic competitions on the planet, largely due to its impact on communities right across the country. However, its most attractive quality is competitiveness, and this is best showcased in the FA Cup.

Teams across all divisions have the chance to play against each other, which occasionally sees semi-professional ‘non-league’ sides the opportunity to play against a giant, such as Manchester United or Liverpool. 

Often referred to as the ‘magic’ of the cup, there is a belief that any team can win on any given day – even if their odds of succeeding are the football equivalent of what David had in beating Goliath.

The magic is in the upsets, and that competitiveness is what ties the whole football pyramid together. For the game in Australia to grow, and to sustain itself,  matches must be competitive from the first minute to the last, from the A-Leagues to the grassroots pitches all across the country.

The importance of grassroots football:

To understand football- from financial investments, market growth, popularity or simply emotional attachment – you have to start at the bottom of the pyramid.

The base of football in every country is the grassroots game. It lays the foundation, and both the future of the A-League and the Soceroos & Matildas is entirely in the hands of the grassroots level. 

Globally, amateur matches are played everyday. Those clubs have a youth system, in which the talent pool is small, and so more established clubs recruit players from that pool. This process continues all the way to the world’s elite. Domestic talent comes from grassroots football, and without domestic talent, the game is nothing.

Once a fire is lit, it needs a constant fuel source to keep it alive. If the wood is wet or rotting, the fire will slowly dissipate into ash. To keep that from happening, the fuel needs to be re-supplied so it steadily grows. Neglecting grassroots football is the quickest way for the game to decline and it is why it is imperative that it is well-funded.

‘Grassroots football is where children start their journey in football.  It’s where players fall in love with the game and develop a passion for playing,’ said Balliana.

‘This not only applies to players, but also administrators, coaches and referees. Grassroots football creates opportunities for all roles across football providing pathways across all levels of the game.’

Recently, Football NSW pledged over AUD $200,000 to three amateur clubs. The funding will allow them to upgrade facilities, create more inclusive and accessible environments and improve the fans match day experience.

Additionally, since 2020 the Dickinson Foundation set up the Active Kids Grant and has provided over AUD $5.5 million worth of equipment and uniform to support over 1000 community clubs. In 2026, 40 football clubs were supported nationwide. 

Commitment to grassroots is necessary, nation-wide. With it, clubs can grow and give players the opportunity to improve and be noticed by more established teams. Investing in grassroots football is investing in the future.

Finance and infrastructure:

As the game has grown throughout the pyramid, so too has investment in it. Globally speaking, football is an industry that has boomed in the digital age, and grown beyond what was previously conceived as possible. Some investors were early; others are riding the wave hoping it never breaks, but inevitably it will.

Everything has to peak, yet that doesn’t mean all conclusions are negative Whatever the fate of the financial wave, neither a tsunami nor shallow brake will impact people’s true love of the game. The game may take many forms, but the fans will be there for generations to come.

In 2021, US private equity firm Silver Lake acquired a 33.3% minority stake in the A-League for AUD 140 million that valued the whole organisation at AUD 425 million.

The finances of the APL have been an issue in the years since, and what becomes of their relationship with Silver Lake remains to be seen. In positive news, Network 10 & Paramount+ recently renewed their broadcast deal worth AUD 100million for an additional two years, so interest is there. Domestically, football has plenty of space to grow.

‘There is always a direct relationship between World Cup success and increased participation given the exposure of football is heightened and more people want to play,’ Balliana continued.

‘However, this also comes with challenges as infrastructure is clearly not to the level it needs to be to support the size and growth of football across our region and the country.’

As audiences grow – particularly when it comes to our national teams – the fire will continue to need fuel, and that can only be sourced organically from the ground up.

Through the continued development of grassroots football, football can still grow to be the dominant sport in this country.

Most Popular Topics

Editor Picks

Send this to a friend