Football must set financial rules of engagement following FIFA Forward Enterprise crisis

Never before has football had such deep access to capital, or faced such complex questions about what that means for the future of the sport.

Private equity firms are investing in clubs, institutional investors are moving into stadiums and sports infrastructure, and clubs are looking beyond broadcasting and matchday revenue towards property, hospitality, entertainment and technology.

The question is no longer whether football needs investments. It’s what happens when investment starts influencing the way the game is run.

The issue came sharply into focus this year when FIFA proposed creating FIFA Forward Enterprise, a new FIFA-owned subsidiary that would bring together its commercial and event operations. The concept would effectively place the World Cup, the crown jewel of global football and FIFA’s blue chip stock, inside an investable structure. 

The proposal envisaged raising up to $6 billion by selling minority, non-controlling stakes in the subsidiary to external investors, based on an initial valuation of $29 billion. FIFA said the additional capital would help increase development funding for its 211 member associations.

The proposal triggered a governance crisis, while major questions about Gianni Infantino’s tenure as FIFA President continue.

UEFA, CONCACAF and (to a lesser-extent) the AFC were among the confederations to object, variously stating they had learned about the proposal through media reports rather than through FIFA’s own consultation process.

Amid a firestorm of criticism, the proposal was ultimately abandoned.

Now, Gianni Infantino has proposed an independent review of the organisation’s governance framework for major strategic initiatives, including how responsibility is divided between the president, Bureau, Council and Congress.

That makes this bigger than one investment proposal.

It’s a debate about who should control football’s commercial future.

Capital isn’t the enemy

There is an obvious argument in favour of private investment.

Football is an expensive business.

At club level, the relationship between capital and football is becoming increasingly sophisticated and complex.

RC Lens recently brought infrastructure investor Entrepreneur Equity Partners into its ownership structure, with the club saying the investment will fund development around the Stade Bollaert-Delelis and help create new revenue opportunities beyond matchdays.

Alas, there is a cost that comes with the capital. 

Investors ultimately expect a financial return. This won’t always conflict with supporters’ interests, but it can create different priorities.

Whereas a supporter might value affordability, identity and competitive success, an investor might instead look at property development, hospitality, commercial growth and the long-term value of an asset.

Neither perspective is inherently wrong.

But problems begin when financial objectives and football objectives stop overlapping and start pointing in different directions.

The ownership question

Chelsea provides a useful example of how quickly football ownership can change.

Clearlake Capital has now taken full control of the London club after acquiring the stakes previously held by Todd Boehly and Mark Walter, in a transaction that values the club at around $9.5 billion including debt. Todd Boehly only invested in the club four years ago.

That does not mean Chelsea’s new ownership structure is better or worse than before.

It demonstrates something important about modern football.

Football is becoming an asset class

That is perhaps the biggest change.

Football is no longer simply something wealthy individuals buy because they love the sport.

It is increasingly being viewed by institutional investors as an asset class with multiple potential revenue streams.

That means the investment opportunity can extend beyond owning a club.

There is private capital in stadiums, infrastructure, media rights, technology, sponsorship businesses and surrounding property.

It also explains why the FIFA proposal was so significant.

FIFA was effectively exploring whether the enormous commercial value of its competitions could be packaged into an investable structure.

FIFA argued investors would hold minority positions and would not receive control over sporting decisions or governance. It also argued the additional commercial value could increase funding available to football associations around the world.

That is a legitimate commercial proposition.

But once an asset is valued in the billions and external investors are being invited to participate, questions about control inevitably follow.

Who decides which commercial opportunities are pursued?

What happens when investors want one thing and football stakeholders want another?

And perhaps most importantly, who ultimately gets the benefit from football becoming more valuable?

The danger isn’t investment. It’s misalignment.

Football should not pretend it can grow without capital.

Football today requires enormous amounts of it.

The challenge is ensuring investment strengthens the sport rather than gradually redefining what the sport means to fans.

There are good reasons for clubs to develop their stadiums, diversify revenue and attract institutional capital.

There are also good reasons for supporters, players, federations and communities to ask what they receive in return.

FIFA’s recent episode demonstrates how quickly these questions can become political as well as financial.

The fact FIFA is now considering an independent governance review following such backlash shows the debate is not simply about whether the investment proposal was commercially sensible, but also about how decisions of that scale should be made.

That may be the most important question for football’s next financial era.

Private capital is here to stay. The tap isn’t turning off.

So, it’s critical football determines its rules of engagement before the next billion-dollar proposal lands on the table.

Previous ArticleNext Article

FIFA lose court ruling to UEFA over scuppered FFE plan

Last Thursday (Nov 12), a New York City judge denied requests made by FIFA subsidiaries to block a move by UEFA, who filed court documents in August pursuing information relating to FIFA President Gianni Infantino’s failed World Cup private investor plan.

Nine days after the 2026 World Cup, FIFA and Infantino officially put forward the FIFA Forward Enterprise proposal (FFE) which shook the football world to its core.

The plan was to sell a minority stake (roughly 20%) in the governing body’s competitions to private investors, but was cancelled in the following days due to intense backlash and boycott threats from UEFA and CONMEBOL, and varying levels of distaste from other confederations.

Lawyers representing UEFA are seeking evidence from Joshua Kushner’s New York investment firm Thrive and FIFA advisors JP Morgan surrounding the FIFA backed investment plan.

In an eight-page document written by the judge, they said the attempted block by two FIFA subsidiaries failed because they “do not have a direct, substantial and legal protectable interest” in the proceedings. 

‘Nothing in this record indicates that the U.S. FIFA parties, or even FIFA itself, will be parties in the contemplated criminal proceedings,’ the ruling stated.

After the immense fallout between FIFA and UEFA, Infantino said the project had ‘created divisions’ and become ‘no longer in the interest’ of its original objective.

The FIFA President had offered its 211 member associations $40 million USD ($59 million AUD) if they supported the proposal which would see all FIFA competitions privately invested in, including the men’s and women’s World Cups.

The investment would have seen the younger brother of U.S. President Donald Trump’s son-in-law, Jared Kushner, be the financial anchor of the venture. 

The fallout of FFE was undeniably the biggest crisis Infantino has faced during his near-eleven-year stint as FIFA president, although he remains the favourite to win reelection for another term in March.

Football Victoria campaign for upgrade to Baranduda Fields

Football Victoria is partnering with the local community of Wodonga in advocating for a significant expansion of Baranduda Fields to help accommodate the rapid growth of football participation in the region.

Wodonga, a growing regional city south of the Victoria/New South Wales border, has seen involvement in football increase by over 130% in just six years.

A massive part of that is the growth of women’s & girl’s football, with participation increasing by almost 300% in the last six years alone.

With such a dramatic rise, the current facilities are not able to meet the demand. 

Alongside the local community, Football Victoria is campaigning for a synthetic pitch and lighting infrastructure to be provided for Baranduda Fields. This would provide players the chance to play year round, including at times when the weather may preclude use of traditional pitches.

It would not only help Murray United FC, who play and train there, but create a regional football hub capable of supporting the increase in activity within the local area.

Football Victoria’s Head of Government Relations & Facilities, Lachlan Cole, said in a press release, ‘The growth of football across this part of Victoria has been extraordinary, and the numbers tell only part of the story.’

‘Football Victoria has a strategic commitment to regional football, and Baranduda Fields gives us the opportunity to think beyond one club for the benefit of a whole region,’ he said.

Whilst the demand for football continues to grow across the country, areas like Wodonga are feeling the exponential rise more than others. Particularly highlighted by the dramatic increase in female participation, the need for upgraded accommodation is no longer a future consideration.

Speaking to Football Victoria, Murray United FC Chairman Pedro Afonso said, ‘A synthetic pitch and lighting would unlock much-needed access to the regions first synthetic football pitch, which provides major benefits to all year round participation and provides access in all weather conditions.’

‘More space and capacity gives Murray United and the sport in the region ability to keep growing. The demand is here – we need the infrastructure to match it.’

Whilst the games grows, the facilities need to be available to sustain it. Football Victoria’s pledge to help maintain that is exactly what the next generation requires.

Most Popular Topics

Editor Picks

Send this to a friend